A place for English speaking sofrim (scribes), magihim (examiners), rabbis and vendors of Stam (Torah, Tefillin and Mezuzah scrolls) from around the world to communicate, share ideas, ask questions and offer support and advice.
I asked a rov from eretz Yisrael that is involved in stam and batim manufacture told me that the Rama Mipano in his teshuvos brings such a shita and that there are those in Eretz Yisrael that manufacture teffilin like this to be yotzi his shita as the Rama Mipano was one of the chashuvei gurei ari
Wot?
ReplyDeleteThis is beyond unbelievable! Had no one noticed for all the years?
ReplyDeleteSome J4Js have "shittas" about what their so-called tefillin should look like. Could your customer have gotten it from one of their online stores?
ReplyDeleteNeed to find out where they were sourced
ReplyDelete???? surely some kind of prank? Are these for real?
ReplyDeleteI asked a rov from eretz Yisrael that is involved in stam and batim manufacture told me that the Rama Mipano in his teshuvos brings such a shita and that there are those in Eretz Yisrael that manufacture teffilin like this to be yotzi his shita as the Rama Mipano was one of the chashuvei gurei ari
ReplyDeleteאני לא מאמין שמישהו יגיד דבר כזה !!
Deleteזה נגד גמרא מפורשת במנחות (דף לה) שרק שתי פרשיות חיצוניות רואות אויר ושתי פרשיות פנימיות אינן רואות את האויר
גם הסתכלתי בשו"ת רמ"ע מפאנו סימן קז ולא נזכר כלל סברא כזו
I asked him where it is brought down he didn't remember I told him i think its a Christian thing and he said no there is such a shita
Delete